Welcome to Shaner's Pizza - Gulf Gate Sarasota
Located at 6500 Superior Ave in Sarasota, Florida, Shaner's Pizza - Gulf Gate is a culinary gem renowned for its exceptional thin crust pizza. Patrons rave about the perfectly cooked crust, rich sauce, and an ideal balance of fresh toppings, making it a standout choice for pizza lovers. The menu is diverse, featuring Italian classics like Chicken Parmesan and Stuffed Shells, alongside tantalizing appetizers and salads. Customers appreciate the friendly service and the welcoming atmosphere, enhanced by owner Shane Rawley’s personal touch. With prices that won't break the bank, this local favorite is a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly delightful dining experience.
-
6500 Superior Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States6500 Superior Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States Hotline: +1 941-927-2708
Welcome to Shaner's Pizza - Gulf Gate Sarasota, where a passion for pizza meets the vibrant ambiance of Sarasota, Florida. Located at 6500 Superior Ave, this culinary gem is not just another pizza joint; it's a destination for pizza lovers seeking a delightful dining experience.
At Shaner's, the star of the show is undoubtedly the thin crust pizza. Customers rave about the perfect balance of crunch and flavor, with many acknowledging it as the best they've encountered in years. Whether you're craving a classic Margarita, Shane's Favorite with its exquisite toppings, or the hearty Meat Lovers variety, each pie showcases an expert sauce-to-cheese-to-topping ratio that leaves patrons wanting more. One reviewer even noted that it rivals the best pizzas in Chicago, which speaks volumes about the quality here.
But pizza is just the beginning. The menu features a diverse selection of dishes, including meatball subs, Philly cheese steaks, and hearty dinners such as Chicken Parmesan and Stuffed Shells. For those looking to lighten things up, the range of salads like the Caesar and Greek are fresh and flavorful complements to any meal.
The atmosphere at Shaner's is warm and inviting, enhanced by the friendly service from staff and the personal touch of owner Shane Rawley, a former MLB player. Patrons appreciate the welcoming environment and the attentiveness of employees, creating a dining experience that feels like home. And for those who enjoy a drink with their meal, the full bar offers a selection of beer on tap, bottled beer, and house wines—perfect for winding down after a long day.
Shaner's Pizza is more than just a restaurant; it’s a community hub for those who cherish great food and good company. With plenty of street parking and a dedicated following, it’s clear why locals and visitors alike are drawn to this treasured spot. Don’t miss the chance to experience a slice of Sarasota's best—head over to Shaner's Pizza for a meal that truly delights.
Really good thin crust pizza-10/10 The ideal bite... crust is perfectly thin and expertly cooked. Taste-wise was delicious, we ate the whole thing. Great sauce/cheese/topping ratio. The first pizza we’ve had in Sarasota that I can say we thoroughly enjoyed. We’re from Chicago so it’s been hard to find something even close in comparison. Highly, highly recommend. A great pizza experience.
Superb thin crust pizza! Excellent flavored and textured crust! Excellent sauce and cheese! Toppings were fresh and crisp!
Another great place to eat in Sarasota, florida. The food was great. The service was great, thank you, Betsey. Head over and get you some great pizza!
For those of you that follow me, you know that I really enjoy searching out great locally owned restaurants!! Shaner's Pizza Gulf Gate in Sarasota Florida is one of those hidden gems that I discovered tonight. Without a doubt, probably the best thin crust pizza I've had in years Friendly and courteous staff, which is a huge plus nice menu selection. Full bar availability Street parking available, and we found one right in front ! To top things off, Shane Rawley, owner and former MLB player was there!! He visited with us, and several other tables. So, I highly recommend Shaner's Pizza give them a try
One of our favorite places to go to in Sarasota. Always a great meal and prices are very reasonable. My favorite is their Philly cheese steak. Shane is there most of the time and works hard just like any employee and a super nice guy. Would patronize his place over pretty much any restaurant in town. Highly recommend!
Owned by former Major League Baseball All-Star Shane Rawley this is a hidden gem tucked away in the Gulf Gate area of Sarasota. The walls are covered with baseball photos, and other MLB themed decor. The thin-crust pizza is second-to-none in the area, with generous helpings of pepperoni. My wife ordered their pasta and meat sauce, which comes with a salad and garlic bread. For the pasta she chose the spaghetti. To say my wife liked it does an injustice to how good it was. I say this because my wife is very particular about meat sauces to where it is rare she finds a location that a sauce she actually likes. Taking the risk at Shaner's paid off as she enjoyed her meal, as well as the two large piece of garlic bread. The salad? Oh, it was so large that it could easily be a meal in and of itself. It filled me up so much I could only eat half the pizza. This was fine with me as I was able to take the rest home and enjoy the next day. Shane Rawley may not have been a Cy Young winner during his career (he was a very good and quality pitcher, though) his Shaner's Pizza is definitely an award winner.
Highly recommend Shaner's in Gulf Gate. Been there for lunch twice now, have tried their pizza, salads (chopped and antipasto), and jalapeno poppers. All have been outstanding, they're nice folks, laid-back vibe... great place!
Always has a local vibe and yummy food. I love the shells, good portion sizes. However, be warned that the food comes out sizzling and could burn pretty bad if you aren't careful with your plate.